
Stay Alert: Scammers Continue to Target NY Physicians
Friday, November 13, 2026

Attorney General James Releases Guidance on New York’s Shield Law & New Resources to Protect Patients & Providers
New York Attorney General Letitia James announced this week guidance outlining New York’s Shield Law protections for physicians, healthcare providers and others who deliver or help others in accessing reproductive and gender-affirming care. The guidance explains what New Yorkers must do if asked for information about protected care, when information can be legally shared, and how New York protects people from improper attempts to investigate or punish that care. The resource is for patients, families, health care providers, attorneys, businesses, and anyone else who may receive a subpoena or other request for information about legally protected health care.
New York’s original Shield Law, passed in the wake of the U.S. Supreme Court decision in Dobbs v. Jackson, bars out-of-state government entities from helping to penalize protected health care. In December 2025, Governor Hochul signed Shield Law 2.0, which extends protections to more providers, including therapists, speech pathologists, and other mental health practitioners. It also establishes processes governing the disclosure of protected health information. The guidance outlines and explains these new protections. New York has some of the strongest protections in the country for reproductive and gender-affirming health care, and the guidance is designed to make sure people know what those protections are and how to use them.
The Office of the Attorney General (OAG) is also encouraging New Yorkers with questions about the Shield Law to read the guidance carefully. Relevant documents can also be uploaded at www.ag.ny.gov/shield-law-notice and questions about the guidance can also be directed to [email protected].
NY AG James Announces Enforcement Action on Health Plan Vendor for Widespread “Ghost Networks” Blocking Patient Access for Necessary Treatment
This week, New York Attorney General Letitia James announced two settlements with Carelon Behavioral Health, Inc. (Carelon) after two Office of the Attorney General (OAG) investigations found that Carelon misled New Yorkers searching for mental health care by directing them to providers who were unavailable and improperly denied coverage for substance use disorder treatment. Carelon administers behavioral health benefits for several health plans, including Emblem, Anthem Blue Cross Blue Shield, Independent Health, and the Empire Plan, the health plan for state and local government employees. Under the settlements, Carelon will pay $2.35 million in penalties, fees, and costs, provide up to $8 million in restitution to eligible members who paid out-of-pocket for out-of-network mental health care, repay other eligible members for out-of-pocket payments for bills denied by Carelon, and overhaul its provider directories and substance use disorder coverage reviews. Eligible members can seek reimbursement for care received as early as January 1, 2020.
Carelon is responsible for the mental health and substance use disorder coverage of more than four million New Yorkers across a variety of health plans. Through two investigations, OAG found that Carelon violated a 2015 agreement with OAG that required it to, among other things, maintain an accurate provider directory, ensure an adequate provider network, and only use approved criteria when reviewing requests for substance use disorder treatment.
Ghost Network Investigation. The OAG’s first investigation found through a secret shopper study, that Carelon’s online provider directories contained many errors, including listings for providers who were unreachable, no longer practicing, not accepting new patients, or not actually in-network. The consequences for New Yorkers were significant. Learn more details from AG James’ report about the enormous impact to patients, particularly those living with mental health and substance abuse disorders.
Lastly, to improve access to mental health care, Carelon must develop a plan to recruit and keep behavioral health providers, reduce administrative burdens, and invest in recruiting child and adolescent psychiatrists and psychiatric nurse practitioners. An independent monitor will audit Carelon’s provider directories, appointment availability, out-of-network use, and behavioral health reimbursement rates and network size compared with medical care, and report to OAG every six months.
Substance Use Coverage Denial Investigation. The OAG’s second investigation examined how Carelon decides whether to cover addiction treatment. Going forward, Carelon must use only OASAS-approved medical necessity criteria and review each member’s full case file, including their diagnosis, symptoms, treatment goals, substance use history, co-occurring conditions, and the risks of stopping treatment. Carelon may deny coverage only when treatment does not meet OASAS standards. The company is also banned from minimizing withdrawal symptoms, requiring patients to fail at a lower level of care before approving a higher one, or requiring proof that a patient poses a risk of serious harm to themselves or others.
Last Chance to Urge Congress to Protect Medicare Physician Payment
Congress is almost done for the year. With year-end legislation looming, this is our last chance to enact meaningful legislation. MSSNY, together with the AMA and medical societies across the country are urging physicians to contact their representatives and senators and ask them to include three Medicare physician payment priorities in an end-of-year legislative package:
- Prevent the impending 2.3% Medicare cut.
- Enact the bipartisan Provider Reimbursement Stability Act (H.R. 8163/S. 5180).
- Delay implementation of the recently announced modifier-25 payment reduction.
Together, these provisions would provide needed near-term stability while advancing broader Medicare payment reform. Medicare physician payment is falling further behind the cost of care.
According to the American Medical Association, when adjusted for inflation, Medicare reimbursement for physician services has declined 33% from 2001 to 2026. The physician fee schedule is also the only major Medicare payment system without automatic inflation-based updates. That problem is getting worse. CMS projects that the cost of running a medical practice will rise another 2.6 percent next year. And CMS just finalized yet another cut: starting Jan. 1, Medicare will reduce payment when a physician provides a separately identifiable office visit and a minor procedure on the same day. A one-year delay would keep this new cut from adding to the strain on practices. Without congressional action, practices will face even greater financial strain, putting access to care at risk for Medicare patients, especially in rural and underserved communities.
Congress must also fix a major flaw in the payment system. When Medicare overestimates how often a new or updated service will be used, it cuts payment across the board for all physician services to offset spending that never actually occurs. Under current law, those mistakes are never corrected, so the cuts become permanent.
The Provider Reimbursement Stability Act would fix that by requiring CMS to correct these errors using actual data. The House Ways and Means Committee has already approved the bill unanimously, 44-0, and that’s momentum we can use!
Take action now: Contact your representative and senators and urge them to include these three priorities in an end-of-year legislative package.
The first two provisions are important steps toward the broader reforms in the bipartisan Patients First Act (H.R. 9693). The Patients First Act includes this same budget neutrality fix plus automatic, inflation-based updates. Acting now would help lay the foundation to finish the job next Congress.
Physicians need a stable Medicare payment system to keep caring for patients in their communities.

What the MLMIC and MSSNY Relationship Means to New York Physicians
By John C. Lombardo, MD, FACS, Chief Medical Officer, MLMIC Insurance Company
For more than 50 years, the relationship between MLMIC Insurance Company and the Medical Society of the State of New York (MSSNY) has represented far more than a business partnership. It is a shared commitment to supporting physicians, protecting practices, advocating for quality patient care, and helping healthcare professionals navigate an increasingly complex medical environment.
Our story began during one of the most challenging periods in New York healthcare history. In response to the medical professional liability crisis of the 1970s, MSSNY played an instrumental role in the formation of MLMIC, ensuring that physicians across New York State had access to stable, reliable medical professional liability coverage. Since that time, MLMIC has remained the trusted and exclusive medical professional liability partner of MSSNY, and together our organizations have continued to evolve to meet the changing needs of New York physicians.
Today, that partnership remains as relevant and important as ever.
A Shared Mission
At their core, both MSSNY and MLMIC are focused on supporting the success of physicians and healthcare organizations throughout New York State.
MSSNY serves as a powerful advocate for the medical profession, representing physicians on legislative, regulatory, and public health issues that impact patient care and medical practice. MLMIC complements those efforts by providing industry-leading medical professional liability insurance, risk management resources, claims expertise, and physician-focused educational programs.
Together, our organizations are united by a common goal: helping physicians focus on delivering exceptional patient care while providing the resources, guidance, and protection necessary to succeed in today’s healthcare environment.
This collaborative approach has allowed us to create meaningful value for physicians at every stage of their careers, from newly licensed physicians just entering practice to experienced healthcare leaders overseeing large medical groups and health systems.
Advocating for Physicians Through Legislative Leadership
One of the most valuable aspects of the MLMIC and MSSNY relationship is our shared commitment to keeping physicians informed about legislative, regulatory, and legal developments that impact the practice of medicine in New York.
Healthcare legislation continues to evolve at a rapid pace, creating new challenges and opportunities for physicians and healthcare organizations. From liability reform and healthcare regulations to workforce issues, reimbursement challenges, and emerging legal concerns, physicians need trusted advocates who understand both the clinical and legal implications of policy decisions.
That is why the longstanding collaboration between Marc Craw, Executive Vice President and General Counsel of MLMIC, and Morris Auster, General Counsel of MSSNY, is so important. Together, they help monitor, analyze, and communicate legislative and regulatory developments that affect New York physicians while serving as strong advocates for the medical profession.
As healthcare continues to become more complex, this collaboration remains an essential resource for physicians. It helps ensure that New York’s medical community remains informed, engaged, and represented on the issues that matter most to their practices, their patients, and the future of healthcare.
Delivering Meaningful Savings
One of the most visible examples of our ongoing collaboration is the MLMIC/MSSNY Preferred Savings Program.
Recognizing the importance of helping physicians manage practice expenses, MSSNY and MLMIC worked together to create an exclusive opportunity that provides qualifying MSSNY members with a 10% discount on their MLMIC medical professional liability insurance premium. Eligible physicians may also qualify for additional discounts that can increase total savings opportunities significantly.
The Preferred Savings Program reflects an important principle that has guided our partnership for decades: finding practical ways to support physicians, reduce burdens, and deliver tangible value.
Collaborating to Educate and Inform
The relationship between MSSNY and MLMIC extends beyond insurance and savings programs. Our organizations continually work together on educational, marketing, and business initiatives designed to keep physicians informed about emerging risks, regulatory developments, patient safety trends, and practice management strategies.
Healthcare continues to evolve rapidly. Physicians need trusted sources of information that understand both the clinical and business aspects of medicine. By combining MSSNY’s advocacy leadership with MLMIC’s expertise in risk management, claims, and medical professional liability, we are able to provide resources that are practical, relevant, and specifically tailored to New York healthcare professionals.
Looking Toward the Future
As healthcare continues to transform, the partnership between MSSNY and MLMIC will continue to evolve as well.
While much has changed over the past five decades, one thing has remained constant: a shared dedication to the physicians who care for New Yorkers every day.
We are proud of the history that MSSNY and MLMIC have built together. More importantly, we are excited about what lies ahead. By continuing to work collaboratively, we can help physicians navigate today’s challenges, prepare for tomorrow’s opportunities, and continue delivering the high-quality care that patients across New York deserve.
On behalf of everyone at MLMIC, I would like to thank MSSNY and its members for their continued partnership, trust, and commitment to the medical profession. We look forward to building on this strong foundation for many years to come.
If you have any questions, please don’t hesitate to reach out to us, we are available 24 hours a day, 7 days a week at 1-(800)-MLMIC.
Stay Alert: Scammers Continue to Target New York Physicians
MSSNY is reminding members to stay alert to fraud schemes aimed specifically at physicians. A member recently reported receiving a letter purportedly sent by a law firm. The letter stated that a grateful former patient had left the physician a large inheritance and asked that the member contact the law firm to claim it. The member smartly referred the letter to the proper authorities and asked MSSNY to warn colleagues. The mailing is a reminder that scammers see physicians as attractive targets. Their contact information is easy to find, they’re assumed to be financially comfortable, and they’re very protective of their licenses and reputations.
Schemes like this come in many forms. In recent years, physicians have been targeted by callers, emails, and letters claiming to come from the Drug Enforcement Administration, the state medical board, or other regulators. Typically, the “agent” claims the physician’s DEA registration or medical license is under investigation, has been suspended, or is linked to drug trafficking. The physician is then pressured to pay a “fine,” “bond,” or “settlement,” or to confirm a DEA number, NPI, Social Security number, or banking information. Scammers may fake caller ID, cite real-sounding case numbers, or send official-looking documents with agency seals. The DEA has repeatedly stated that it does not contact registrants by phone to demand money or threaten arrest.
The pitch changes from scam to scam, but the warning signs stay the same:
- Urgency or threats. There’s a short deadline or a threat of arrest, license action, or losing a large sum of money.
- You’re warned not to discuss the matter with anyone.
- Unusual payment methods. You’re asked to pay by wire transfer, gift card, cryptocurrency, or another method you can’t trace.
- Requests for credentials. You’re asked for DEA, NPI, license, or financial information.
- One contact only. You’re told to deal only with the person who contacted you.
- Too good to be true. The message offers something unexpected, such as a windfall, bequest, or prize.
Protect yourself and your practice:
- Don’t reply, call back, or click on links or attachments in a suspicious message.
- Check any claim independently by calling the agency or organization at a number you look up yourself.
- Never pay money or share credentials because of an unsolicited demand.
- Report suspected fraud to the DEA (for impersonation of the DEA), the FTC at ReportFraud.ftc.gov, the U.S. Postal Inspection Service, the FBI’s Internet Crime Complaint Center at ic3.gov, or local law enforcement.
- Train your front-desk and billing staff, who are often the first to receive these contacts.

Action Alert: Incorrect Insurer Processing of Office-Administered Drugs (UnitedHealthcare)
MSSNY is currently tracking a systematic claims processing issue involving UnitedHealthcare and physician-administered drugs billed on CMS-1500 claims forms.
What Happened
- The Issue: Claims for physician-administered drugs given in an office setting were incorrectly processed and paid under the patient’s pharmacy benefit rather than their medical benefit.
- The Result: Office appeals were repeatedly denied, with the plan incorrectly claiming the processing was correct.
- Resolution: Following direct leadership escalations by MSSNY, UnitedHealthcare confirmed processing errors on a sample case involving over $4,000 in owed reimbursement for an oncology practice—stretching back three years—and agreed to reprocess and pay out the claims.
How MSSNY Can Help You
If your practice has experienced any of the following over the last 3 years, we want to hear from you:
- Billed physician-administered drugs on a CMS-1500 form that paid under a pharmacy benefit.
- Had formal appeals rejected by UnitedHealthcare with claims that the processing was “correct.”
- Received improper denials or takebacks related to office-administered specialty drugs.
MSSNY is actively identifying other impacted practices to ensure all affected claims across New York State are properly audited, reprocessed, and paid.
Contact Us
If you or a colleague have impacted claims, please reach out directly:
- Contact: Heather Lopez, Vice President of Physician Payment and Practice
- Email: [email protected]
Office Phone: 518-328-3532

Responding to Medicare Cuts & the Impact of Election Results on Healthcare

Upcoming MSSNY Webinars Support Physicians Across Every Career Stage
November 18
Beyond the Acute Infection: A Mechanism-Based Approach to Diagnosing & Managing Post-Viral Syndromes. Learn more about diagnosing and treating patients experiencing Long COVID and other post-viral syndromes, with Robert Groysman, MD, Founder of Southwest Pain Management and the COVID Institute in Texas.
Antisemitism in American Healthcare: From Research to Action. Examine how antisemitism manifests across healthcare settings and discuss the steps institutions can take to address discrimination, strengthen accountability, and foster safer, more inclusive environments.
December 2
The Insurance Mistake Physicians Can’t Afford to Make. What Every Physician Should Know About Disability Insurance.
December 8
Beyond the Bedside: Protect Your Practice. Common legal and financial risks in practice arrangements and how to reduce exposure.

Your Career. Your Opportunities. Your Next Move.
MSSNY is proud to launch the new Career Care Center, powered by MDUO.ai, an exclusive member benefit designed to help New York physicians make informed career decisions.
Whether you’re exploring new opportunities, evaluating an employment contract, or comparing compensation, the Career Care Center provides AI-powered tools and personalized resources to help you navigate your career with confidence.
Your MSSNY membership now includes access to:
- Compensation Insights: Explore New York-specific salary benchmarks tailored to your specialty, experience, and career stage.
- AI-Powered Contract Analysis: Review employment agreements and better understand key terms in plain language.
- CV Assistance: Build and strengthen your professional profile to highlight your qualifications.
- Physician Career Opportunities: Discover New York physician positions matched to your experience, preferences, and career goals.
- Career Care AI: Get confidential guidance on professional and career-related questions.
Your next career move starts here. Access the Career Care Center using your existing MSSNY login. Explore Career Center

Seeking Physician Co-Tenant In NYC
Brand New Fully Built Medical Space
Medical Office for Lease (Great Neck, NY)
Medical Space to Share, Mount Sinai (Suffolk North Shore)
Madison Avenue – Park Medical Space Midtown East to Sublet
Medical Space to Share Great Neck/Manhasset
Medical Office Space Available for Sublet
Office Space for Rent — Flatiron District
30 Central Park South Office Space for Lease
Park Avenue Medical Office for Sale
Prime Midtown Boutique Medical Office Sublease
On Park Ave at 80 St: Large and Beautiful Office to Share
Empire State Medical, Scientific & Educational Foundation Needs Peer Reviewers










